A senior New York police officer is under investigation after allegedly firing an accidental shot during a personal dispute in Rockland County. The incident involved an off-duty NYPD assistant chief and his daughter’s boyfriend. Thankfully, no one was injured, but the case has raised questions about the circumstances that led to the gun being discharged.
What Happened in Haverstraw
According to law enforcement sources, Benjamin Gurley, who oversees the Bronx North command, was involved in a physical fight late Sunday night in Haverstraw, New York.
The dispute reportedly involved a man accused of harassing Gurley’s daughter. Sources said the man is believed to be dating her. During the heated confrontation, Gurley allegedly fired a stray or accidental shot.
No one was struck by the bullet. However, Gurley suffered an arm injury during the altercation and is expected to wear a sling while recovering.
Multiple Investigations Underway
The incident is being investigated by several agencies.
The Haverstraw Police Department responded to the scene and is leading the main investigation.
At the same time:
- The New York City Police Department (NYPD) Force Investigation Division is reviewing the firearm discharge.
- The NYPD Internal Affairs Bureau is also conducting a separate internal probe.
According to reports, Gurley’s duty status has not changed following the incident. This means he has not been suspended or removed from his role at this time.
About Assistant Chief Benjamin Gurley
Benjamin Gurley joined the NYPD in 2000. Over the years, he rose through the ranks:
- Promoted to Deputy Chief
- Elevated to Assistant Chief in 2023
He currently oversees the Bronx North command. Gurley is described as a first-generation police officer who was born and raised in the Bronx. He is also a father of three.
Earlier this year, he spoke publicly about how difficult it can be to earn promotions within the NYPD. He said that seeing others move ahead can be discouraging, but added that things have improved in recent years.
Location and Context
Haverstraw is located about 30 miles north of the Bronx, in Rockland County. The incident happened while Gurley was off duty.
Because a firearm was discharged — even accidentally — strict procedures require both criminal and internal reviews. Police departments usually examine:
- Whether the weapon was handled properly
- If department guidelines were followed
- Whether any disciplinary action is needed
So far, authorities have not announced any charges.
What Happens Next
The investigations will determine whether the discharge was truly accidental and whether any laws or departmental rules were violated. Officials will likely review witness statements, body camera footage (if available), and forensic evidence.
Although no one was hurt, the case highlights how personal disputes can quickly escalate, especially when firearms are involved. It also shows how law enforcement officers are subject to internal and external investigations when incidents occur — even while off duty.
As the review continues, more details may emerge about what led to the confrontation and how the firearm was discharged. For now, authorities confirm that no injuries were caused by the gunshot, and the assistant chief remains on duty pending the outcome of the investigation.
